Translation
Proofreading
Proofreading is the step in comic translation where an editor checks the translated script for errors, natural flow and consistent terms before it is lettered.
Proofreading turns a correct translation into a readable one. The proofreader checks spelling, grammar and punctuation, but also whether a line sounds like something a person would say, whether names match earlier chapters and whether each character keeps a voice. In a scanlation team, the proofreader (PR) works between the translator and the typesetter.
What does a proofreader check?
- Errors. Spelling, grammar, punctuation, typos.
- Flow. Lines that are correct but stiff, or too long for the balloon.
- Consistency. Names, places, attack names and honorifics that match the series bible.
- Voice. A rude character stays rude, a formal one stays formal.
- Meaning. A bilingual proofreader also checks the translation against the source.
How is proofreading different from quality check?
| Step | Works on | When |
|---|---|---|
| Proofreading | The script (text only) | Before typesetting |
| Quality check | The finished lettered page | After typesetting, before release |
In professional publishing, the same work is often split between a translator, an editor and a copy editor. Webtoon publishers work to weekly deadlines, so proofreading is often short and done on the script in a spreadsheet.
A short example
The translator wrote 'I will not forgive you for this matter.' The proofreader changes it to 'I won't let this go.' Both are correct. The second fits a teenage character and a small balloon.
How Bublate handles proofreading
Bublate runs a review pass after translation that checks each line against the source and the series bible. A person still makes the final call: the page editor shows the source next to the output, so a proofreader can change any line in place. See for translators.