Comparison
Ichigo Reader vs Immersive Translate: which is better for manga?
For manga alone, Ichigo Reader is the simpler choice: it is built only for manga, takes ZIP and PDF chapters, and costs $5.99 a month for unlimited extension use. Immersive Translate is better if you also translate web pages, PDFs and video subtitles, because one plan covers all of them. Its pricing table lists comic translation on the paid Pro and Max plans.
Table of contents
Side by side
| Ichigo Reader | Immersive Translate | |
|---|---|---|
| What it issource | A manga translator for Japanese, Chinese and Korean | A general translator for web pages, PDFs, ebooks, subtitles and images, with a manga mode |
| Pricesource | Free trial, Tier 1 $5.99 a month, Tier 2 $19.99 a month | Free plan, paid Pro and Max plans with a 3-day free trial |
| Comic translationsource | Every plan. The free trial has 40 extension translations and 20 uploads in total | Listed on Pro and Max, 3,000 images a month. Not listed on Free |
| Browserssource | Chrome | Chrome, Edge, Firefox, Safari on Mac, and a userscript |
| Appssource | iPhone, iPad and Mac, Android | iPhone, iPad and Mac, Android (Google Play or APK) |
| Uploadssource | PDF, ZIP and images | JPG, JPEG, PNG and WEBP, in batches |
| Translation enginessource | Its own model menu, with more models on Tier 1 and Tier 2 | 16+ engines, including OpenAI, DeepSeek and DeepL |
| Chrome Web Store userssource | 40,000 | 3,000,000 |
| Datasource | Handles website content, not sold to third parties (store disclosure) | Says it does not retain translated content or use it for model training |
Ichigo Reader and Immersive Translate both translate manga in the browser, but they come from opposite ends. Ichigo is built only for manga. Immersive Translate is a general translator for web pages, documents and video, and manga is one of its many modes. Every fact below comes from their own sites and store listings, opened on 8 November 2026. Every browser option is in manga translator extensions compared.
What does each one do with a manga page?
Both find the text on the page, erase it and set the translation in its place. Ichigo translates Japanese, Chinese and Korean into 18 languages, and its Chrome Web Store listing says the extension "works on every manga site with the Unlocker or Panel Tool". Ichigo's own site now says the Unlocker has been deprecated, so on sites that block extensions it points to the translation panel or to Firefox. On its site you can upload a PDF, a ZIP or images, and Tier 1 adds full context and a glossary on PDF and ZIP uploads.
Immersive Translate's manga page says it uses OCR and inpainting to erase the dialogue and place the translation inside the bubbles. You right-click a manga image on a supported site, or upload JPG, PNG or WEBP files to its web app in batches. Its store listing says it "supports targeted online manga sites", so check that your site is one of them.
How much does each one cost for manga?
Ichigo's free trial gives 40 extension translations and 20 image uploads in total. Tier 1 is $5.99 a month with unlimited extension translations (subject to its terms) and 300 uploads an hour. Tier 2 is $19.99 a month with Tier 2 models, English OCR and no watermark.
Immersive Translate has a free plan and two paid plans, Pro and Max, each with a 3-day free trial. Its plan table lists comic translation at 3,000 images a month on Pro and on Max, and not on Free. The free plan lists offline image translation. Its manga page, on the other hand, says the image translation feature is free and that Pro gives higher OCR accuracy. The pricing page showed us prices in local currency, so we do not quote a dollar figure. Check the plan table in your own currency before you subscribe.
Which browsers and devices do they run on?
| Platform | Ichigo Reader | Immersive Translate |
|---|---|---|
| Chrome | Yes | Yes |
| Edge | Not listed | Yes |
| Firefox | No add-on found | Yes, desktop and Android |
| Safari | Through the Apple app | Yes, on Mac |
| iPhone and iPad | App | App |
| Android | App on Google Play | App on Google Play or APK |
Sources: Ichigo's Platforms menu and App Store listing, Immersive Translate's download menu and Firefox add-on page.
What happens to your pages?
Immersive Translate's pricing page says it does not retain translated content and that translation results are never used for model training. Its Chrome Web Store listing limits the training promise to "the scope of applicable official translation services", so a custom engine you add follows that engine's own rules. Ichigo's Chrome Web Store disclosure says the extension handles personal information, authentication information and website content, and that the data is not sold to third parties. Its privacy notice is about personal information and does not discuss the pages you translate.
What neither one does
Neither describes a comic page editor, so a wrong name or a cut-off line stays as it is. Neither lists sound effect redraws, so effects drawn into the art mostly stay in the source language. If you need to fix the text, compare Torii vs Ichigo Reader or the open source Koharu vs manga-image-translator.
If you make or publish the comic
Both tools are for reading. If the pages are yours and you want a translated edition, Bublate is a web app that letters each bubble, redraws sound effects, keeps names consistent with a series bible, and gives an editor for the final check. It costs $3 for a webtoon chapter of up to 20 segments with 30 free credits. Manga and other print pages cost up to $0.60 a page. See Bublate vs Ichigo Reader, Bublate vs Immersive Translate and sound effect translation.
Which one fits
Pick Ichigo Reader if manga, manhwa and manhua are what you translate, you want to drop in a ZIP or PDF chapter, and a flat $5.99 a month suits you. Pick Immersive Translate if you already use it for web pages, papers or subtitles, read in Firefox or Edge, or want to choose between many translation engines. For comic translation on Immersive Translate, plan on a paid Pro or Max plan.
Frequently asked questions
Is Immersive Translate made by Google?
No. Immersive Translate is made by Funstory.ai Limited, a company in Hong Kong, according to its own site and its App Store listing. It can use many translation engines, and its pricing page names DeepSeek, DeepL, OpenAI, Claude and Gemini models among them.
Can Immersive Translate translate manga images?
Yes. Its manga page says it reads the text, erases it and places the translation inside the bubbles, and that you can right-click a manga image on a supported site or upload JPG, PNG or WEBP files in batches. Its pricing table lists comic translation on the Pro and Max plans.
Does Immersive Translate work for manga?
It works on images, and its manga page lists batch translation for chapters and webtoons. It is a general tool, so it does not offer manga-only features such as a glossary on ZIP uploads. Try it on a few pages from your usual site before you pay for a plan.
Is Ichigo Reader better than Immersive Translate?
For manga only, it is simpler: one purpose, ZIP and PDF uploads, and unlimited extension translations on Tier 1 for $5.99 a month. Immersive Translate is better value if you also translate web pages, PDFs and videos, and it works in more browsers.
Do Ichigo Reader and Immersive Translate work on Firefox?
Immersive Translate has a Firefox add-on for desktop and Android. Ichigo lists a Chrome extension, an Apple app and an Android app, and we found no Ichigo add-on on addons.mozilla.org on 8 November 2026. For more browser options, see our manga translator extension comparison.
Can I edit the translated page?
Neither tool describes a page editor for comics on its site or store listing. You get the translated image to read. If you want to move text, fix a line or change a font, look at Torii, mangatranslate.com or Koharu, which have editors.
Sources
- Ichigo, home page and Platforms menu · checked
- Ichigo, plans · checked
- Ichigo, Unlocker page (deprecation notice) · checked
- Ichigo, upload page and target languages · checked
- Ichigo, privacy notice · checked
- Ichigo, Chrome Web Store listing and privacy practices · checked
- IchigoReader, App Store listing · checked
- Immersive Translate, manga translator page · checked
- Immersive Translate, pricing and plan table · checked
- Immersive Translate, Chrome Web Store listing · checked
- Immersive Translate, Firefox add-on · checked
- Immersive Translate, App Store listing · checked