# Lettering QA Checklist for Translated Comics

## Fit and placement

- [ ] **Every line sits inside its balloon with air on all sides.** Comicraft calls this space "air" and suggests about one letter width. Text that touches the edge is "gridlock".
- [ ] **The text block follows the balloon's shape.** A round balloon takes a round block, not an hourglass or a box.
- [ ] **One size for normal speech across the chapter.** A balloon that is bigger or smaller than its neighbours reads as a shout or a whisper.
- [ ] **No text stretched or squashed to fit.** Re-break the lines or ask for a bigger balloon instead.
- [ ] **No balloon edge sits on a line of the art or the panel border.** Comicraft calls this a tangent. It makes the balloon read as an object in the scene. Move it a little.
- [ ] **Balloons cover no faces, hands or key objects.** Comicraft defines placement as leading the reader's eye from panel to panel without covering figures or key objects.
- [ ] **A single word alone on the top or bottom line is fine.** Comicraft says widows are acceptable at the top or bottom of a balloon. A lone word in the middle is not.

## Tails and reading order

- [ ] **Each tail points at the speaker's mouth.** Blambot says a tail should end at roughly 50 to 60% of the distance from the balloon to the head.
- [ ] **Tails follow a curve from the balloon's centre toward the mouth.** Comicraft's [Creating Tails and Joins](https://balloontales.com/creating-tails-and-joins/) describes this "invisible curve".
- [ ] **Thought balloons have a tail of small circles** pointing at the head, as Blambot describes.
- [ ] **Balloons read in the order the source intends.** English balloons read left to right and top to bottom, and Comicraft puts the tail on the leftmost balloon of a pair so readers know at once who speaks. A manga that keeps its [right to left](https://bublate.com/glossary/reading-direction) page order keeps its source balloon order.
- [ ] **No tail crosses another tail.** Crossed tails make readers guess who speaks.
- [ ] **Joined balloons (one speaker, two beats) stay joined.** A split pause in the source is a split pause in the translation.

## Comic grammar

- [ ] **Interrupted speech**: A double dash, exactly two dashes, only when speech is cut off. American comics use no em or en dash.
- [ ] **Trailing speech**: An ellipsis of exactly three periods. If the line goes on in the next balloon, end and start with one.
- [ ] **Double dash or ellipsis**: They are not interchangeable. Cut off is a dash, fading out is an ellipsis.
- [ ] **Emphasis**: Bold italic on the stressed word. There is almost no plain bold in dialogue.
- [ ] **The crossbar I**: Only for the pronoun "I" and in acronyms. The plain I everywhere else.
- [ ] **Shouted question**: "?!" only for a shouted question, with the question mark first as a loose rule.
- [ ] **Whisper**: Traditionally a balloon with a dashed stroke. Grey text, small text or italics are newer options. Pick one for the series.
- [ ] **Breath marks**: Three short strokes on each side of a non-word sound such as a sigh or a gasp. Comicraft calls them fireflies.

## Fonts and licences

- [ ] **One dialogue font for the series**, with its bold italic for stress. A font change mid-series looks like an error.
- [ ] **The font has every character the language needs.** Many free comic fonts lack accented letters, the ellipsis or the tilde. Missing glyphs fall back to another font. See [free lettering fonts](https://bublate.com/guides/free-webtoon-lettering-fonts).
- [ ] **The licence covers this use.** Blambot's free fonts for indie comics allow flattened web images "even if you are making money", but a comic from a mainstream publisher needs a paid licence. Read the [font licence](https://bublate.com/glossary/font-licence) entry.
- [ ] **OFL fonts are fine in sold images.** The SIL OFL FAQ says a graphic made with an OFL font is not itself subject to the OFL.
- [ ] **The font file goes with the delivery only if the licence allows it.** Send the font name and source, not the file, when in doubt.

## Size for each platform

- [ ] **Standard text is inside 12 to 30 px at the upload width.** The WEBTOON handbook says most creators use this range. Check the smallest text at 690 px if you export for Naver.
- [ ] **Export each platform from a master wider than its upload width.** Scaling down keeps lettering sharp, scaling up blurs it. See [webtoon sizes](https://bublate.com/guides/webtoon-export-sizes).
- [ ] **Read one full page on a real phone** before you sign off.

## Sound effects

- [ ] **Every sound effect follows the series rule:** redrawn in the target language, kept with a small caption, or left. Mixed rules look like misses.
- [ ] **A redrawn sound effect keeps the size, angle, colour and outline of the original,** so it still reads as part of the art.
- [ ] **Each sound effect means what the source means.** Check the reading in an [SFX dictionary](https://bublate.com/sfx/korean), because a misread sound becomes a wrong word.
- [ ] **No source letters are left half erased** around a redraw.

## Words, names and consistency

- [ ] **Names, places and forms of address match the [series bible](https://bublate.com/glossary/series-bible).** One spelling per name, the same honorific choice every time.
- [ ] **Run a spell check on the script, not only on the page.** Add the bible's names to the dictionary first, so real errors stand out.
- [ ] **Each character keeps their voice.** A rough speaker does not turn polite in one balloon. See [consistent character voice](https://bublate.com/guides/consistent-character-voice).
- [ ] **Repeated lines read the same.** A catchphrase changes only when the source changes it.

## Compare with the source

- [ ] **Count the balloons.** Every source balloon has a translated one, and no balloon is empty.
- [ ] **No source text is left in balloons, captions, signs, phones or notes** that the series rule says to translate.
- [ ] **Side text and small text outside balloons are lettered too,** or listed as kept on purpose.
- [ ] **Line breaks do not change the meaning,** for example a joke whose punch word moved to the wrong balloon.
- [ ] **The final page matches the approved script.** Check that late edits reached the page.

## Credits

- [ ] **The letterer is credited as agreed,** next to the translator and the original creator.
- [ ] **Credits required by a font or an image licence are present.**

Source: https://bublate.com/guides/lettering-qa-checklist
Version: 2026-11-20
